Freedom Insider

By StarCityFan

To make a long story short, I have been persuaded by my friends and fellow fans that my WPS boycott is going rather too far. So I have renewed my season tickets and am getting back into the fannish swing of things. This doesn’t mean that I’ve forgiven Hope Solo, the Atlanta Beat general manager who refuses to admit that Solo still needs to apologize, or the league for not stepping in. And there will still be consequences. I’ve done a lot in support of the Freedom and WPS that I didn’t really enjoy doing very much. That’s done. From here on out, I’m going to do what I like, and the heck with the rest. Fortunately for those of you who like to read this blog, writing about the Freedom is something I very much enjoy doing. So enough about me – let’s move on to that.

How big was Saturday’s win? Just about everyone realized that Saturday’s match against Sky Blue FC, our rival for the fourth and final playoff spot, was a big deal. However, math major that I am, I computed the odds and figured out just how big a deal it was. So I’m going to give the standard win-or-go-home playoff game a 100, that being the difference between the odds of advancing if you win (100%) and if you lose (0%). Doing a quick-and-dirty calculation based on the possibilities ensuing from Saturday’s match, I figured that if the Freedom had lost, they’d have about a 3% chance of making the playoffs – if you simplify the possibilities to just wins and losses, there was only 1 scenario out of a possible 32 that had Washington in the playoffs: the Freedom would have had to win both of their remaining matches, while Sky Blue lost all three of theirs. On the other hand, with a win, there are 26 permutations out of 32 that put the Freedom in the playoffs. Assuming that all possibilities are equally likely, that’s an 81% chance of getting in. So the StarCityFan Significance Factor (SSF) is 81-3, or 78, which isn’t that much less than a playoff match.

How big is Sunday’s game? Thus emboldened by my initial calculations, I put together a more sophisticated model to figure out how important Sunday’s match against Chicago is, given the current standings. I was somewhat surprised at the results. My current estimate of the odds of the Freedom making the playoffs is 70.48%. (I’m only putting in the two decimal places to keep from putting down a very approximate-looking 70%. Even I’m not that anal!) That’s based on weighting all of the possible results of the remaining four relevant matches (two each for the Freedom and Sky Blue), including ties. If Washington wins on Sunday, that goes up to 92.8%. If they lose, that drops to 30.4%. So the SSF is 62, still a pretty big number (A tie leaves them at 80.8%, so not losing is much more important than winning). More significantly, losing would mean that the Freedom have lost control of their destiny: even if they beat Atlanta the following weekend, they could still miss out on the playoffs if Sky Blue wins their two remaining matches.

But how good is Chicago, really? You’d think we wouldn’t have to worry too much about a team that would consider themselves fortunate at this point to finish in fifth place out of seven teams. However, they just had a solid showing against Philadelphia, winning 2-0, and their signing of Spanish international Veronica Boquete, fresh off playing for the undefeated W-League champion Buffalo Flash, has paid dividends already as she got the game-winning goal in that match. With nothing to play for, they would certainly like nothing better than to mess up the Freedom’s finish as they may well have done already with the Independence. Meanwhile, Washington is far and away the worst road team in the league, with a mere one road win on the season, and that one was against the Atlanta Beat before their infusion of Athletica players. But if they’re going to pull one out, now’s the time. You might remember that last year the Freedom went into Chicago needing a win and pulled one out off a superb late goal from Allie Long.

Can the Freedom earn a home playoff game? The surprising answer to this one is yes. If Washington wins out while Philadelphia loses their one remaining match, then the first playoff match will be at the SoccerPlex, just as it was last year. That may seem like a long shot, but really the only unlikely part of it would be Washington beating Chicago. After that, the Freedom come home to play the last place Atlanta Beat. Philadelphia, meanwhile, has to finish by flying to the West Coast and playing FC Gold Pride, who have only lost one home match all season. So, particularly given the Freedom’s road ineptness this year, this is certainly something we should be hoping for.

Bookmark to:

By StarCityFan

[Editor's note: The following represents StarCityFan's own personal opinion and does not necessarily reflect the opinion of Jim Higgins (owner/operator of Freedom Insider), Freedom Insider nor any other members of the Freedom Fighters.]

There are several supporters groups for the teams in Women’s Professional Soccer. Despite the team rivalries, we are all first and foremost WPS fans, so there’s considerable solidarity among us. When the Boston or Chicago fans are coming down to the Soccerplex for a match and need travel advice, I’m glad to provide it. When I went to St. Louis for last year’s All-Star Game, I had dinner with members of Laclede’s Army. When I’ve gone up to Boston, the Riptide have allowed me to share in the repast from their tailgate parties. So you can imagine how I felt after coming home from last Wednesday’s Freedom match, going online, and finding that Hope Solo had posted the following to Twitter:

To all the boston fans and especially the young kids that I didn’t sign autographs for I’m sorry. I will not stand for…An organization who can so blatantly disrespect the athletes that come to play. Perhaps the WPS or Boston themselves…Can finally take a stance to the profanity, racism and crude remarks that are made by their so called ‘fan club’…To the true fans, I hope to catch you at the next game. Thanks for your support and love for the game.

Now, there’s no love lost between Hope Solo and the Riptide, who sometimes refer to her as “Public Enemy No. 1,” but this is taking things to a whole ‘nother level. Such an accusation, if upheld, would lead to severing any ties between the team and the supporters group and barring the members from attending any future matches. Note also that it’s actually a two-part accusation:

1. “profanity, racism, and crude remarks” were made at Wednesday night’s match
2. This is standard operating procedure for the “fan club”

Needless to say, the Riptide and everyone who knew them was shocked at this statement, and the Riptide quickly posted a rebuttal on their website, denying any such behavior and concluding with

It’s fine if Hope Solo doesn’t like us. It’s fine if she lets us get into her head and upset her during games. It’s not fine that she accused us of racism, and we won’t stand for it. We ask that she either explain her remarks or retract them.

I sent an email to the league office the next morning, noting the seriousness of the allegations and insisting that an investigation be initiated to determine what actually happened. Speculation was rampant online about what Hope Solo actually heard, if anything, or if she was just carrying out a grudge against a supporters group after she let them get into her head in a match her team lost.

The following afternoon, Atlanta’s general manager, Shawn McGee, announced that the matter was being looked into:

At this point, we have no comment. We are in the process of gathering information regarding the incidences at the match last night and will work with the Breakers management to ensure that everything gets handled appropriately. Racism and inappropriate comments of any nature have no place in the beautiful game. The Breakers, the Beat and WPS will work together ensure that the pitch is a place to celebrate the sport and the great athleticism of our players…and is a safe place to do so.

That didn’t do much to squelch speculation. On Friday, it was announced that a statement would be forthcoming Monday, and late that day such a statement appeared. I defy anyone to find it who isn’t looking for it, and it’s not accessible at all from the main WPS website, but you can read it here on Atlanta’s section of the website or here on Boston’s. As it turns out, there was some “abusive language” used during the game, though none of it could be attributed to Riptide. The most relevant portion, from a supporter’s perspective, was the following:

The coordinated review of the Breakers and the Beat also conclusively showed that at no time was there any organized or coordinated singing or chanting of racially insensitive slogans or profanity by the Riptide supporters group or any other group of fans. The Beat regret that a member of their organization used social media to make public allegations against the Breakers organization and its supporters group without first bringing her concerns to the attention of either club. The Beat and its players understand that the remarks were from a few individuals and not representative of the Breakers organization or the Riptide supporters group.

I find this seriously lacking, for the following reasons:

1. There’s no actual apology or consequences here. If I falsely or erroneously accused one of my company’s best customers of racism, in a very public way that could potentially have driven them out of business, then I would be lucky to keep my job. At the very least, I would have to make a very clear and abject apology to said customer. Why isn’t Hope Solo required to do this?
2. There is an implication that, even if the Riptide as a whole didn’t make abusive comments, individual members did (Just see the comments posted below the statement, particularly the Atlanta version, for people who have accepted this implication). Unless there is clear evidence that an actual member of the supporters group made such statements, the group and all its members should be exonerated.
3. Even if this statement were adequate, it’s buried in the WPS website. Hope Solo has over 1800 followers on Twitter, most of whom, unless they’re reincarnations of Sherlock Holmes, still think that the Boston supporters are a pack of racists.

I sent an email to the league office and to the two teams noting my objections to the statement and had a short back-and-forth with the Atlanta GM, who was unrepentant. At this point my impression is that WPS is turning into yet another league that, rather than putting the fans first, is intent on coddling its marquee players no matter what they do. If you agree with me, or at least think that the official response to Hope Solo’s accusations is inadequate, please take a few minutes to send an email to the following to register your objections:

• WPS Chief Operating Officer Mary Harvey – Mary(dot)Harvey(at)womensprosoccer(dot)com
• Atlanta Beat General Manager Shawn McGee – SMcGee(at)theatlantabeat(dot)com
• Boston Breakers General Manager Andrew Crossley – ACrossley(at)bostonbreakers(dot)com

(Remove the parentheses and change the words to their corresponding punctuation to create a legal email address – as annoyed as I am at this point, I will still do them the courtesy of not exposing their addresses to spam email harvesters.)

If you think I’m overreacting, feel free to tell me by commenting below.

As for me, at this point I am boycotting WPS other than using up the season tickets that I’ve already paid for. I will not be writing any more WPS-related blog posts, buying any merchandise, renewing my season tickets, nor continuing to operate the Freedom Fighters supporters group until our cohorts in Riptide have received an apology proportional to the serious accusation leveled by Ms. Solo. The one relevant expenditure I will be making is to have a t-shirt made that reads “Hope Solo Called Me A Racist”, which I will be wearing to the few remaining WPS matches I plan to attend, most notably the one on September 11, when the Freedom take on the Atlanta Beat.

Kevin W. Parker
“StarCityFan”
Ex-President
Freedom Fighters
The Washington Freedom Supporters Club

Bookmark to:

By StarCityFan

The Freedom went through the entire months of June and July without a single victory. You’d think that would kill any hope of making the playoffs, but it hasn’t. In fact, the Freedom are currently in fifth place, one point out of the fourth and final playoff position.

Right now I’m predicting a 2-2-2 finish, which gives them 28 points come the end of the season and should be just enough for the fourth and final playoff spot. Their next game is at Rutgers against a struggling Sky Blue FC team. I’m figuring a tie in that match. After that, they play the league-leading FC Gold Pride on the West Coast, which I doubt they’ll get points out of. Then they finish the season with three out of four games at home: Chicago on Thursday the 19th (one of the games added to the schedule after Athletica folded), Sky Blue on the 28th and Atlanta on September 11. The one final road game is against the Red Stars on September 5. I figure they should be able to get at least two wins and a tie out of that stretch.

All this of course assumes that their performance against Philadelphia on Wednesday night is now the standard, rather than how they’ve played in most of their prior summer matches.

One promising note is that the surprise of Wednesday’s lineup was the lack of surprise: Every player was in her accustomed position on the field: no more benching Cat Whitehill, throwing Nikki Marshall up front, or pulling Sonia Bompastor to the back line. I get the feeling that Jim Gabarra just told the team, “Okay, I’m not going to tweak, I’m just going to put our best XI out their in their best positions. The rest is up to you.” To the relief of Freedom fans everywhere, the team responded, pulling together and working hard for 90 minutes to produce a convincing 2-0 win against the No. 2 team in the league.

So I’m hoping that that result is the new normal, while June and July will become just a bad dream. Last year set a possible template, as the Freedom came off a three-game losing streak going into their final six matches but finished 4-1-1 to make it into third place. That, interestingly, also started with a weeknight match in New Jersey.

And, for what it’s worth, the Freedom had a similar season in 2003, when they started strong, stumbled badly in midseason, then recovered with help from a series of outstanding performances by Abby Wambach to claw into the playoffs in the fourth and final position. From there, they won two consecutive away games, one against the regular-season champions, to claim the final WUSA championship. Let’s hope that history repeats itself this year.

Bookmark to:

I feel like the Washington Freedom are playing right now – lousy.

I’ve spent a lot of time traveling lately with another week on the road before I am back home and I am already run down. Sitting here on the West Coast, I imagine things are that much different for the Freedom – mired in a terrible losing streak with no sanctuary in sight.

If you can’t hold on to a lead against the last place team in the league, where are you going to catch a break?

While the losses continue to mount, so do the calls to fire Jim Gabarra. But let me ask you this – will a coaching change really turn this thing around? I think the truth of the matter is that Gabarra doesn’t have the necessary pieces to keep things going. A couple of months ago this team was on a roll and everything looked good. Now things have gone from bad to worse and the Freedom are stuck trying to break out of a funk relying a lot more on unproven rookies and young players then previously thought.

Jeff Kassouf of The Equalizer tackled this question earlier this week and right now I stand behind his argument of patience. But as GM Mark Washo said, this is a team that expects to win championships and a 9-game winless streak is not going to accomplish that. If things don’t turn around soon, Gabarra may find he has finally run out of time.

That’s too bad though in my opinion given the fact that Gabarra stuck with the Freedom through all sorts of uncertainty. But this is pro sports and often times the right decision and the hasty decision often conflict, usually ending in a coach looking for a new job.

Those are my thoughts as we head into the weekend taking on a Breakers squad the Freedom always seem to struggle with, so now I ask you – should Gabarra stay or go?

LINKS

I’ve been sitting on some of these for a while so I apologize if some of these are a little stale. I did try to weed out the ones that no longer apply so hopefully these are still good reads. Enjoy.

• Washington Freedom could join Crystal Palace Baltimore downtown stadium if approved (The Equalizer) – Ah, the old stadium story. Would be interesting to see though if a change of venue would increase ticket sales given that Baltimore is a lot more accessible than Germantown.
• Freedom, WPS heed lessons of history (Gazette.net) – Coaching, stadiums and league sustainability; it’s been a rough time for the Freedom and rough times seem to bring out the core stories and arguments. This story is from the local Gazette and does a good job of reminding us that there is still a long way for the league to go.
• WPS Restructuring Means Loss of Jobs, Move Towards Decentralization (All White Kit) – As someone who lost his job during a front office restructuring, you hate to see news like this. But then again, this all goes back to what will allow the league to sustain itself and hopefully these moves will have a positive impact on the long term plan.

Bookmark to:

I discussed this topic a little in my recap of Sunday’s loss, but it’s something that I’ve heard being discussed a lot lately so I thought I would delve into the topic a little more. Can anyone out there tell me what’s going on with Alex Singer?

The No. 8 overall pick in the 2009 WPS Draft, Singer was a key piece on last year’s Freedom backline, starting 13 of 16 games for a total of 1,143 minutes. Granted, her playing time tapered off as the season went on but a lot of that seemed to be due to a concussion she suffered midseason. She had played every minute of every game to that point and seemed adept at holding her own against the top-level talent in this league.

At the conclusion of the season, Singer seemed to be in good enough shape that she went with F Lisa De Vanna to play in Australia’s W-League and from all accounts it seems she played well there. And she seemed to be doing well enough that she earned a spot on the Freedom’s protected list. In fact, it seemed more people were concerned about why we were keeping Allie Long over Lori Lindsey.

So, if Singer was considered one of the 10 best players on the team at the time of expansion, what happened since then? She has logged only 60 minutes in 4 games played, and was one of only two players not to play last week when the team was extremely short-handed.

I don’t know how much sense it makes to shake up a defense that has produced 4 shutouts already but given the fact that the Freedom have struggled to score since learning De Vanna broke her leg while on Australian National Team duty, it seems like it might make sense to move Rebecca Moros or Nikki Marshall up top so Lene Mykjaland and Christie Welsh can revert back to their roles coming off the bench since they seem to be more productive in that sense.

Moving Moros or Marshall would then open a spot on the backline and given Singer’s experience starting with Cat Whitehill and Becky Sauerbrunn last year, doesn’t that seem like it would be a natural evolution of the lineup? The one wrinkle to all this is it seems Kristi Eveland has earned the role as the first defender off the bench but maybe it makes more sense to keep the rookie in that role and see if Singer still has what it takes to contribute to this squad. If she can’t, then maybe she needs to be the next one to go.

I hate sitting here at my computer and second-guessing Jim Gabarra’s decision not to play Singer because truthfully I have no idea what is going on behind-the-scenes. It could very well be that Singer suffered an injury in practice at some point and isn’t fit to play or it could be that she really has fallen that low on the depth chart. But since I can’t find any mention of either of things, I can only sit her and postulate on what I know. And what I know is Alex Singer used to be considered a top defender on this team and now she isn’t.

Hopefully as Gabarra continues to tinker with his lineup in an effort to jump start his club, he will keep Singer in mind. And hopefully if I’m missing something really obvious in this situation, someone will be kind enough to let me know.

Bookmark to: